Sunday, September 28, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 381: It's Not Real's City Anymore
Monday, May 26, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 363: Three Legends Sign Off
The end of the Premier League and La Liga seasons also meant the end of the stints of three of the all-time greats—two players and a manager—at their respective clubs. Luka Modrić and Kevin De Bruyne wrapped up their tenures of 13 and 10 years at Real Madrid and Manchester City respectively while in Real’s dugout, Carlo Ancelotti concluded his second spell at the helm of Los Merengues; his return to the Santiago Bernabéu took his total time spent in the role to six years.
All three were able to finish on a high note: Real Madrid beat Real Sociedad while Manchester City beat Fulham; both wins were by 2-0 scorelines. In Real’s match, a Kylian Mbappé brace was enough to secure Real’s victory; as for City, İlkay Gündoğan’s spectacular bicycle kick put them a goal ahead before half-time; after the break, Erling Haaland’s penalty made all three points safe.
However, given the events of the day as well as the fact that both teams had already clinched Champions League qualification for next season, the actual results of both matches seemed almost inconsequential - and understandably so. Modrić, Ancelotti, and De Bruyne leave as unquestioned legends of their clubs with impacts that will forever resonate at the Bernabéu and the Etihad Stadium.
Just a few months after Modrić signed for Real back in 2012, no one would ever have believed that more than a decade later, the Croatian would be leaving the club to a standing ovation from the entire Bernabéu and a guard of honour not only from his teammates, but even Real’s opponents on the day. His time in the Spanish capital certainly didn’t start as he’d hoped - such were his early struggles that Modrić was commonly cited as the worst signing of the 2012-13 seasons.
As the years passed, though, things would change. Modrić would cement himself as an indispensable part of the Real team which would win three consecutive Champions League titles from the 2015-16 to 2017-18 seasons and become not only one of the best midfielders in the world, but of all time. Modrić’s crowning achievement was, of course, winning the Ballon d’Or in 2018. He leaves Real having represented the club in almost 600 matches and having won four La Liga titles and a joint-record six Champions Leagues.
Having coached Real to the Champions League title in 2013-14 before being somewhat surprisingly fired after a trophyless season a year later, Ancelotti returned in the 2021 off-season with unfinished business - and it didn’t take him long at all to right that wrong. In his first season back at the Bernabéu and third overall, Ancelotti helmed yet another Champions League title run to go with a La Liga title - the fourth Champions League of his career including the two he won with AC Milan in the 2000s.
Two years later, Ancelotti would once again take Real to a league and Champions League Double. With five Champions League titles under his belt, Ancelotti leaves to take over as the Brazil national team’s new head coach as clearly the greatest of all time - at this point there isn’t really a reasonable case to be made for anyone else anymore.
Over in England, De Bruyne’s final match for City came as a substitute to a rousing reception, entering to a standing ovation of his own. A decade ago, De Bruyne arrived at the Etihad as one of the most promising young midfielders in the world, fresh off winning the Bundesliga’s Player of the Year award with VfL Wolfsburg in the 2014-15 season. De Bruyne soon emerged as one of the best midfielders on the planet; he was an integral part of six Premier League titles as well as City’s Champions League title run in the 2022-23 season - part of only the second Treble to be won by an English club.
Twice selected as the Premier League Player of the Season, De Bruyne played over 400 matches at City over his remarkable career. A statue of the Belgian which will stand outside the Etihad has now been confirmed to be in the works; it’s a well-deserved honour for a player who leaves as perhaps the greatest player in Manchester City’s history.
Although it remains to be seen just how Real Madrid and Manchester City will bounce back from their club icons’ departures, whoever replaces them will certainly have some of the biggest shoes to fill.
Saturday, February 8, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 348: Indicative of Greater Struggles or Rounding Into Form Just in Time?
Before their blockbuster Champions League clash against Manchester City, Real Madrid first had to get through the Madrid derby in the league. This was an especially high-stakes derby because cross-town rivals Atlético Madrid trailed Real by just one point in the league. The winner of the match would leave the Santiago Bernabéu top of the league and deal a severe blow to their rivals’ title chances.
As things turned out, though, both teams finished as they started; the match ended in a 1-1 draw. After a little over a half-hour was played, French midfielder Aurélien Tchouaméni surrendered Real’s first penalty of the season after fouling Atlético’s Samuel Lino who’d been attempting to finish off a cross played in by Javi Galán. Julián Alvarez then stepped forward to convert the penalty.
Atlético carried their lead into the half-time break; however, it didn’t take Real much time after the interval to score the equalizing goal. After Jude Bellingham’s initial shot was blocked, Kylian Mbappé was right in position to finish off the follow-up attempt. Following this, Real went on to firmly control the match throughout the second half but, as so many have found over the years, Diego Simeone’s Atlético team are probably the most difficult team to chip away at; their frequent attacks on the Atlético net following Mbappé’s goal yielded nothing further.
Although Real might currently be in first place in La Liga, that doesn’t tell the whole story. This has certainly been a more difficult campaign for Real than what they’d likely have envisioned when the season began. Real started their league season slowly and only recently took the lead for the first time this season; for most of it they’d been playing catch-up to Atlético and Barcelona. Real’s early-season struggles were punctuated by a 4-0 loss to Barça in El Clásico and arguably encapsulated by Mbappé’s slump which ended up costing them several wins.
However, this doesn’t even compare to what they’ve been through in the league phase of the Champions League. After losing three of four matches, Real were dangerously close to not even making it to the round of 24; they were in 24th place after five matchdays before winning their last three to set up a highly anticipated match against City for a spot in the last 16.
While it’s true that this season hasn’t even been close to peak Real, that may be all that’s needed to win them the league title for the fourth time in the last six seasons. Real are currently on pace to finish the season with 83 points in the league. The last time a total that low would’ve won La Liga was almost two decades ago in the 2006-07 season. That being said, due to Atlético’s and Barça’s own inconsistent form, Real have only needed to be “just better than” the two other title contenders.
Needless to say, performances on this level won’t cut it if Real are to make a genuine run at defending their Champions League title. Although their next opponents have had obvious struggles of their own this season to the point at which most are expecting Real to come out on top against City, it almost certainly won’t be enough against the gauntlet of opponents to come after.
With that in mind, is it possible that Real have been starting to turn the corner and are peaking at just the right time? Heading into the derby, Real had won four of their last five in the league to move into first place; as mentioned earlier, they also finished the league phase of the Champions League with three wins in a row. So many times over the years we’ve seen Real ramp it up and come into form down the final stretch of the season. This could easily be the case once again.
It’s astonishing to think that even in a “down year”, Real Madrid could conceivably end up winning both La Liga and the Champions League. That said, such an outcome isn’t likely to take place with more performances like theirs against Atlético in the derby. However, by now everyone knows better than to dismiss Real way too early - after all, there’s a reason they’re the winningest football club of all time.
Thursday, November 28, 2024
The Weekly Take, Issue 338: Not the Title Defense They'd Hoped For
Real Madrid had already gotten off to a slow start to their Champions League campaign even before their match against Premier League leaders Liverpool. Los Merengues’ title defense had not been going well following prior losses to Lille and AC Milan. For that reason, when Real headed to Anfield to face off against the Reds, it was perhaps their most important match thus far this season - and against a serious contender for the Champions League title, no less.
As things turned out, Real never even stood a chance. The final scoreline of 2-0 to Liverpool was somewhat flattering to Real - it could’ve, and likely should’ve, been larger. Despite dominating the match more or less right from opening kick-off, Liverpool didn’t open the scoring until early in the second half. Alexis Mac Allister played a one-two with Conor Bradley before advancing into Real’s penalty area, then firing a shot into the bottom corner of the net.
Following this, both teams traded penalty misses. Real first had a chance to equalize from the spot after Andy Robertson fouled Lucas Vázquez in the penalty area; however, Kylian Mbappé squandered Real’s opportunity, having his penalty saved by Liverpool goalkeeper Caoimhín Kelleher. Nine minutes later, Ferland Mendy conceded a penalty after his own foul on Liverpool winger Mohamed Salah, only for Salah to blow the ensuing spot-kick; his attempt wasn’t even close.
Liverpool continued to outplay their Spanish opponents in every facet of the game and to the surprise of absolutely nobody, scored their second goal in the 76th minute when Cody Gakpo found the net with a header off a cross sent in by Robertson.
Real’s loss - their third in five Champions League matches this season - leaves them in 24th place at the end of the fifth of eight league phase matchdays. In a scenario which would have seemed inconceivable when the season started, Real are in serious danger of failing to even qualify for the play-ins for a spot in the round of 16.
Real haven’t even been close to the force they were just last season when they won their second Champions League title in three seasons and also reclaimed their La Liga title after finishing ahead of arch-rivals Barcelona by 10 points. This season, however, it’s not just about Real’s struggles in continental play - domestically, while not far behind Barça right now, the obvious lowlight of Real’s 2024-25 La Liga campaign to date has to have been their crushing 4-0 home defeat against Barça. Of course, this leads to the question - just what’s going wrong at the Santiago Bernabéu?
A sizable amount of the blame has to be placed on Mbappé. The Frenchman arrived in the Spanish capital over the off-season following the expiry of his contract at PSG, having decided against activating its extension clause. Despite all the fanfare which his arrival at Real brought, Mbappé’s form has been inconsistent since the beginning of the season - a far cry from the level which had previously seen him establish himself as a perennial Ballon d’Or contender.
Real’s injury crisis can’t be overstated either. Among the players currently sidelined are Rodrygo, Aurélien Tchouaméni, and most notably of all, Vinícius Júnior. Would it have been the case that at least one of them would have made the difference against Liverpool? Not necessarily - but when the team sustains such major losses, it means that the entire setup has to be adjusted; against Liverpool, it was obvious that this wasn't what Real was comfortable with.
Speaking of Vinícius, the off-field drama surrounding him and thus Real has undoubtedly been an unwelcome distraction. After finding out in advance that the Brazilian winger would not win the Ballon d’Or, Real opted to boycott the ceremony in Paris - a decision that understandably invited sharp criticism from the football world in general. Real’s detractors have long derided them as the “golden child” of the powers that be; the fact that their refusal to attend the ceremony didn’t lead to any official response further intensified the backlash.
All things considered, while there’s more than enough time for Real Madrid to claw their way back into Champions League or La Liga contention, this definitely isn’t how they envisioned the first third of their season going. They’re not out of it by any means - but it will be a difficult road back.
Sunday, June 2, 2024
The Weekly Take, Issue 312: An All-Time Great Gets the Dream Career Finish
After a 17-year career, one of the greatest midfielders of all time has ended his club football career on a high note - with another Champions League title to his name.
On May 21, Toni Kroos announced his upcoming retirement at the age of 34 via a post on Instagram. The German midfielder’s last matches would be for his national team at Euro 2024, making his appearance in the Champions League final at Wembley for Real Madrid against Borussia Dortmund his club football swansong. Not surprisingly, this became the biggest underlying storyline heading into the match.
Real ended up clinching their sixth Champions League title in the last 11 seasons and a record-extending 15th overall. Although Dortmund had multiple viable goalscoring chances in the first half, Die Schwarzgelbe weren’t able to take advantage of any of them - and as such, they were made to pay after the break. Dani Carvajal put Real a goal ahead in the 74th minute via a header that fittingly, was delivered by Kroos. Nine minutes later, Vinícius Júnior put the result beyond all doubt after finishing off a chance set up by Jude Bellingham, who’d received the ball in a dangerous position following an error by Dortmund full-back Ian Maatsen.
There can be no question that Kroos has done it all. Seven league titles, four domestic cups, a World Cup title with Germany in 2014, and now - by far the most remarkable statistic of the lot - six Champions League titles. Kroos has been an integral part of the greatest dynasty that football has ever seen.
In stark contrast to the exit of Marco Reus, another German veteran who was ending his own legendary 12-year stint at Dortmund, Kroos went out in a blaze of glory. This was a performance in which the man from Greifswald turned back the clock, resembling the player he was at his absolute peak. Kroos was involved in almost all of Los Merengues’ serious attacking thrusts, making countless key passes and setting up multiple goalscoring opportunities - including the one which ended up being Real’s first goal.
Going back to that day almost a decade ago when Kroos first signed for Real, his stock at the time was already high following the major role he played in Germany’s 2014 World Cup triumph. Kroos was signed from Bayern Munich for the now laughably low fee of €25 million. As such, very few at the time could’ve predicted that Kroos would someday go on to become a club icon and a bona fide legend of the Santiago Bernabéu.
By the end of Kroos’ fourth season in Madrid, he’d been one of the core pieces of a historic Champions League three-peat, been named to the FIFPro World XI and UEFA Team of the Year twice as a Real player, and led La Liga in assists in 2016-17. While already an extremely impressive achievement list, Kroos wasn’t even close to done.
Kroos was a major reason why Real didn’t immediately suffer a severe drop-off following the 2018 off-season departure of Cristiano Ronaldo to Juventus. Alongside Luka Modrić and Casemiro, Kroos would establish himself as one-third of the greatest midfield trios ever.
After a lean spell which included back-to-back round of 16 Champions League exits as well as a tame elimination at the hands of England at Euro 2020, some thought Kroos would be in terminal decline from that point on. Instead, Kroos had a bounce-back season in 2021-22, playing an important role in Real’s La Liga and Champions League double before capping it off with another of the same this season.
Taking his entire career into consideration, one can go a step further: Kroos retires as the greatest midfielder to ever come out of Germany. Even compared to icons like Günter Netzer, Wolfgang Overath, Lothar Matthäus, and Mesut Özil, Kroos has surpassed all of them. None of them have the combination of peak level of play, statistical achievements, and individual and team accolades that Kroos has - including (but not by much) Matthäus who was the consensus pick for “greatest ever German midfielder” before Kroos.
With Germany’s national team looking stronger than it has been in years, there’s an opportunity for Toni Kroos to sign off his international career on a high note - if not with a Euro 2024 victory, then at least with a deep run. It would be a fitting way to sign off.
Wednesday, February 14, 2024
The Weekly Take, Issue 297: Rounding Into Peak Form
Wednesday, October 4, 2023
The Weekly Take, Issue 278: "Limitless Potential" Is an Understatement
Sunday, July 23, 2023
The Weekly Take, Issue 267: It Finally Seems to Be Happening
Sunday, February 26, 2023
The Weekly Take, Issue 246: All Their Eggs in One Basket
Monday, October 17, 2022
The Weekly Take, Issue 232: First Blood in the Mbappé Sweepstakes
Real Madrid opened up a three-point lead at the summit of La Liga with a convincing 3-1 victory over arch-rivals Barcelona. Newly-crowned Ballon d'Or winner Karim Benzema opened the scoring; Federico Valverde and Rodrygo also registered goals for the Champions League holders. Ferran Torres scored Barça's only goal seven minutes from the end of regulation time; however, it proved to be inconsequential. Real's El Clásico win clearly established that in spite of their Catalan rivals' highly productive off-season, Real remain the team to beat in Spain.
Los Merengues' victory comes in the wake of transfer-related news that is likely to alter how teams approach the upcoming mid-season transfer window in January. Paris Saint-Germain superstar Kylian Mbappé supposedly claimed to be interested in leaving the club just months after rebuffing Real to continue his stint at his hometown club. While Mbappé has since denied this, the fact remains that the Pandora's Box has been opened; adding to the intrigue of the situation is that Real have been pursuing his acquisition for several years now.
There is arguably no club in world football right now in which Mbappé would be a better fit than Real. As undoubtedly great as Benzema still is, he will turn 35 in December. His decline will begin sooner or later. At 23, Mbappé could easily take over from his compatriot in the starting line-up once Benzema begins to age out of his peak years, then provide a decade of elite-level production up front - or perhaps even more.
Real could not have provided Mbappé with a better sales pitch. If he indeed decides to leave the Parc des Princes for the Spanish capital and become Benzema's replacement, Real would not only be set up for success in the present, but the future as well. Rodrygo, Valverde, and Vinícius Júnior, like Mbappé, are all in their early 20s. As the would-be "face" of the most successful club in football history, Mbappé would get the media attention and publicity he has always craved. He would be the undisputed leader of Real's attack - the pecking order would be firmly defined. There would not be any potential ego clashes with players like Neymar or Lionel Messi.
Mbappé has openly stated that having already won a World Cup with France, his next major target is the Ballon d'Or. There might be no better avenue for him to do exactly that than by joining Real. If Mbappé were to sign for Real, his arrival would make them the red-hot favourites to win the Champions League. As arguably the best player on the likely victors of Europe's leading club competition, one could scarcely imagine a more favourable scenario for Mbappé to snag football's highest individual honour.
As if all of that weren't enough, Mbappé would be coached by none other than the greatest football coach of all time in Carlo Ancelotti. The upgrade in the dugout that he would experience after leaving Christophe Galtier behind would be monumental. Ancelotti's tactical brilliance and supreme strategic mastery could very well unlock a new level in Mbappé's game - one that sees him truly emerge as one of the greatest strikers of all time.
The match against Barça clearly showed how great Real already are. If what they showed Mbappé were not enough to convince him, one wonders just what would. The only question mark is this: after so many failed attempts to sign him in the past, would this be a case of "once bitten, twice shy"? Though it's difficult to determine if such is so, one would not fault Real for having this line of thinking.
Of course, Real are not the only club in the "Kylian Mbappé Sweepstakes". You could easily argue that he'd be a good fit at teams such as Manchester United and AC Milan as well. However, the combination of team quality, coaching, setup, money, publicity, and title opportunities that is afforded by Real makes them the obvious front-runners to sign Mbappé.
Perhaps Mbappé's recent denial of the transfer rumours around him is genuine - he might not truly want to leave PSG after all. Nevertheless, every major club who can afford his signing is surely on high alert, and especially after this most recent victory, Real Madrid evidently have the inside track once again.
Sunday, May 29, 2022
The Weekly Take, Issue 212: A Performance for the Ages
Sunday, February 13, 2022
The Weekly Take, Issue 197: Stumbling Towards the Finish Line
Wednesday, September 15, 2021
The Weekly Take, Issue 176: A Dozen Matches from GOAT Status
Sunday, May 9, 2021
The Weekly Take, Issue 157: Still Up for Grabs
Tuesday, April 6, 2021
The Weekly Take, Issue 153: From Juggernaut to Plucky Underdog
The last time that Real Madrid and Liverpool played a Champions League match against each other, Real clinched their third consecutive Champions League title and fourth in five seasons by beating the Reds 3-1 in the final of the 2017-18 season's tournament. The victory established Real as one of the, if not the single, greatest club team of all time.
Almost three years later, Real are nowhere near the pantheon-level territory they once occupied. They were not expected to be serious contenders for silverware this season; La Liga and the Champions League included. However, they took a step closer to yet another Champions League title by once again beating Liverpool 3-1, this time in the first leg of their Champions League quarterfinal tie. Vinícius Júnior's two goals either side of Marco Asensio's strike gave Los Merengues a commanding lead heading into the second leg. They are now all but certain to make the semifinals for the ninth time in the last 11 seasons.
Real's role reversal since their 2018 triumph has been easily noticeable. Ever since the departure of Cristiano Ronaldo to Juventus that off-season, they have only claimed one title: last season's La Liga title. They have been knocked out of the Champions League in the round of 16 in both of the past two seasons and are not expected to retain their La Liga title.
In addition, unlike what has often been the case, Real Madrid did not make any signings during either of this season's transfer windows. Several players who, while not necessarily regular starters, were nevertheless notable contributors also left the club, significantly reducing the roster's depth.
Real's cause has not been helped by the injury woes of star winger Eden Hazard. Almost inexplicably, Hazard's body seemingly disintegrated upon his arrival at Real from Chelsea in 2019. Prior to the 2019-20 season, Hazard had played in at least 30 league matches in each of the preceding 11 campaigns. Since then, however, the Belgian has only featured in 25 La Liga matches - an alarming figure, considering the fact that Real signed him for an eye-popping €100 million.
Yet somehow, in their new role as underdogs, Real have been defying expectations this season. The recent slump experienced by crosstown rivals and league leaders Atlético Madrid has allowed Real to close to within three points of Atlético. They are also likely to make the Champions League final because they will likely play against Chelsea in the semifinal. This is a matchup which is very much in Real's favour.
Perhaps the most impressive part of Real Madrid's success this season has been the fact that this is an aging squad. Players such as Karim Benzema, Sergio Ramos, Toni Kroos, and Luka Modrić who are all in the latter portions of their respective careers are having impressive seasons. Many would have expected the age-related drop-off to have come this season, but they have clearly staved it off - at least for now.
This season also has to rank among head coach Zinedine Zidane's most impressive coaching displays to date. That may be a very big claim indeed, given the fact that he presided over Real's historic run of three straight Champions League titles. However, when considering the general expectations of Real heading into the season, "Zizou" has exceeded them and then some. Even if Real finish the season without a trophy, Zidane ought to once again be considered for another The Best FIFA Football Coach award - an accolade he last won in 2017.
It is also possible that the lack of expectations has helped Real this season. Over the years, Real Madrid squads have been burdened by the weight of having to live up to the reputation of the world's most successful football club. This in turn has sometimes caused them to underperform on the biggest stages. However, this season, Real have been playing with a lack of inhibition that hasn't always been there in the post-Ronaldo era; it isn't out of the question that this is because of their newfound underdog status.
Though it does not seem likely that Real will add a record-extending 14th Champions League title to their overflowing trophy cabinet this season, for the reasons mentioned, it would be by far their most satisfying and thrilling victory if they were to somehow do it.
Sunday, December 13, 2020
The Weekly Take, Issue 136: They Surely Can't Fire Him Now
The standout fixture of the latest La Liga matchday was the latest edition of the Madrid derby. Real Madrid emerged with an impressive 2-0 victory over city rivals Atlético Madrid. Casemiro opened the scoring in the 15th minute. In the second half, an own goal scored by Jan Oblak off Dani Carvajal's shot that struck the post ensured Real's victory.
Real's win put Los Merengues within three points of Atlético, who currently lead the league. It also eased the pressure on head coach Zinedine Zidane. Rumours that Zidane might soon be fired have been circulating for some time now. They only intensified after a recent slump in form.
However, the events of the derby showed that not only would it be a colossal mistake on Real's part if they were to fire the Frenchman; the club's top brass ought to pull out all the stops to make sure that Zidane remains in the Santiago Bernabéu dugout for the foreseeable future.
Consider the fact that although Zidane was going up against one of the top five overall coaches and perhaps the best pure strategist in the world in his Atlético counterpart Diego Simeone, it was in large part thanks to Zidane that Real Madrid came away victorious. His tactical setup was on point, his substitutions were timely and effective, and he ably adjusted to everything Simeone threw at him. It's not often that a great coach like Simeone is so decisively countered. Yet, that's exactly what happened against Real.
I'd actually say that "Zizou" is the most underrated coach in world football at the moment. After all, no one else has ever led a team to three consecutive Champions League titles - that fact alone speaks for itself. While his detractors may claim that his Real Madrid team of 2016 to 2018 was carried to those titles by Cristiano Ronaldo, consider this: to win those three straight European crowns, Real beat Simeone's Atlético in 2016, Massimiliano Allegri's Juventus in 2017, and Jürgen Klopp's Liverpool in 2018. For those counting, that would be two all-time great coaches and one excellent one.
Last season was Zidane's first full season in his second stint at the helm of Real. Notably, it was also his first full season as Real head coach since Ronaldo's departure for Juve in the 2018 off-season. Despite having a squad which was clearly weaker to that of his first go-around, Zidane led Real to the league title, finishing ahead of arch-rivals Barcelona by five points. This league triumph came despite key players such as Eden Hazard and Gareth Bale missing large portions of the season through injury.
What Zidane had to deal with upon his return to Real cannot be overlooked either. When he replaced Santiago Solari in March 2019, Real were a club in disarray. They were nowhere near either Barça or Atlético in the league. They had also been knocked out of the Champions League in the round of 16 after an upset loss against Ajax. Fast forward almost two years later and Real, despite currently trailing Atlético in La Liga, are likely to claim back-to-back league titles for the first time since 2008. They also topped a tough Champions League group containing Inter Milan, Shakhtar Donetsk, and Borussia Mönchengladbach.
Real's front office is notorious for being trigger-happy with regard to coaches. However, if they break with their history and retain Zidane's services for an extended time period, the club will be likely to experience much current and future success. Given Zidane's track record to date, there is no reason why he shouldn't remain at Real for at least a decade, racking up titles along the way while establishing himself as perhaps the greatest coach in Real's history - and maybe, just maybe, of all time.
It is beyond crucial that Real do not act in their usual knee-jerk manner, especially if results start going against them later in the season. Zidane has clearly built up a body of work which clearly proves that he is an outstanding coach. Firing him would be an epic mistake of almost unparalleled proportions.
The decision should be obvious. Only one question remains: will Real finally "get it", or will they revert to type?