Wednesday, October 22, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 385: A Critic-Silencing Triumph
Monday, August 18, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 375: A Debut That Didn't Fulfill the Hype
The obvious standout of the opening matchday of the 2025-26 Premier League season saw Manchester United host Arsenal. The match was billed as a clash between both clubs’ respective centre-forwards who had just been signed for major money. United signed Slovenian Benjamin Šeško from RB Leipzig for €76.5 million while Arsenal brought Swede Viktor Gyökeres to the Emirates Stadium from Sporting Lisbon for a fee of €65.8 million.
This highly-anticipated showdown got off to an anticlimactic start after it was revealed that unlike Gyökeres who was in the Gunners’ starting line-up, Šeško started the match on the bench. However, it was actually Arsenal’s Italian full-back Riccardo Calafiori who scored the opening goal of the match following - in what has become a common occurrence for Manchester United - an error by United goalkeeper Altay Bayındır who mishandled Declan Rice’s corner kick, allowing Calafiori to put it in from close range.
Despite having the bulk of the goalscoring chances and possession, United were never able to make full use of these advantages and remained a goal behind heading into halftime. After the break, Šeško replaced Mason Mount and thus made his Premier League debut shortly after Gyökeres was substituted; Gyökeres was replaced by Kai Havertz.
However, Šeško’s first Premier League match certainly didn’t go according to plan. Apart from attempting a header which ended up not even being close to the target, Šeško barely did anything of note in his half-hour or so of play as United, despite largely being in control of the match, couldn’t find a way to the back of the net and finally succumbed to a 1-0 loss.
On an individual level, however, Šeško’s opposite number fared even worse. Between the two of them, Gyökeres was by far the more hyped despite having been signed for the lower transfer fee of the two. Adding to the narrative of this match was the fact that at one point of the transfer window, the man from Stockholm arguably seemed to be more likely to sign for United. As such, this match could easily have been an opportunity for Gyökeres to send a clear statement to United: “this is what you’ve missed out on”.
However, Gyökeres barely contributed anything at all - he didn’t even attempt a single shot - before being substituted. United’s Dutch centre-back Matthijs de Ligt got the better of Gyökeres again and again. Gyökeres looked absolutely nothing like the centre-forward who utterly shredded defenses across Portugal for the past two years.
There’s no question that there’s a significant skill gap between the Portuguese and English top-flight leagues. Many players over the years who have dominated a weaker league have found themselves struggling after making a move to a club in one of Europe’s major football leagues. While one would assume that Gyökeres is too good a player for that to happen to him and of course, it’s only been one match, we’ve seen players come into one of the top leagues from a weaker one with plenty of hype before - only to never live up to said hype.
It should go without saying that if Arsenal are to make a serious push for a first Premier League title since 2004, the North Londoners will need Gyökeres to rediscover his peak form and sustain it. Last season, Arsenal scored 22 fewer league goals than they had the season before - and this relative lack of goalscoring output caused Arsenal to finish the 2024-25 Premier League with 74 points as opposed to 89 in 2023-24. A tally of 89 points would, in fact, have won them the league last season.
On the surface, Gyökeres appears to check every box as far as what Arsenal need in a centre-forward. In addition to goalscoring, Gyökeres has a blend of technical skill and athleticism that not many strikers can boast of; he’s even above average compared to other centre-forwards at creating goalscoring chances. However, the gap between the Premier League and the Primeira Liga coupled with the fact that there’s more pressure on him than there has been on any Arsenal signing in a long time might just cause him to be unable to fulfill the hype.
All of that being said, most would say that Viktor Gyökeres does have what it takes to become Arsenal’s next great striker. However, if he’s to do so, performances like the one he just had against Manchester United won’t cut it at all.
Sunday, July 20, 2025
The Weekly Take, Issue 371: Another Botched Transfer Window?
Not long after returning from the United States with the Club World Cup in possession after destroying Paris Saint-Germain in the final, Chelsea soon picked up another W - this time off the field; specifically, after flat-out scamming Arsenal in their sale of winger Noni Madueke to their London rivals for a transfer fee of £48.5 million.
In the two seasons and a half that Madueke spent at Chelsea, he showed absolutely nothing even remotely resembling the level of play that would’ve merited his hefty transfer fee. While Madueke is no scrub by any means, based on what we’ve seen from him so far, his ceiling isn’t anywhere near as high as his transfer fee - almost one and a half times his projected transfer value - might indicate.
As for Arsenal, they appear to be once again fumbling the transfer window - the main reason why the Gunners haven’t won a title of any sort since their FA Cup victory in the 2019-20 season. This can clearly be seen not only by the fact that they significantly overpaid for Madueke, but also in how they’re struggling to close out a huge transfer deal that seemed to be a lock not too long ago: the signing of Swedish striker Viktor Gyökeres.
After looking so close to landing by far their biggest signing since Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang from Borussia Dortmund in January 2018, progress on Gyökeres’ move to Arsenal has stalled and even more gallingly, might be beaten to the punch by Manchester United - a team which finished just 15th in the Premier League last season in what was their worst league campaign in 51 years and realistically should have no business landing a player on Gyökeres’ level.
If Arsenal are to seriously challenge Liverpool and Manchester City on the domestic front next season, they absolutely have to get things right in the transfer window. Instead, what they’ve been doing so far has been the exact opposite. Going back to the signing of Madueke, it was an obvious panic move which showed absolutely no forethought whatsoever; on top of the excessive transfer fee, it remains to be seen just how he will slot into Arsenal’s starting 11 - if he even can. There’s a possibility that Arsenal just spent all that money to bring in an expensive benchwarmer.
The argument that Arsenal don’t have the financial might that City do isn’t a viable one either; Liverpool just won the league by a landslide last season and they too aren’t working with that kind of budget. For years now Arsenal have been playing catch-up in the transfer window; if not for that, it’s very possible that Arsenal’s trophy drought wouldn’t have stretched to five years by now.
To put into perspective how pessimistic Arsenal fans are about the Madueke signing, after it was confirmed that it was likely that Madueke would be signing for Arsenal, many Arsenal fans took the the internet with the hashtag #NoToMadueke. While it’s of course not out of the question that Madueke defies the critics and has a career-best year in his first season at the Emirates Stadium, everything around the move is really not looking good as of right now.
There’s no good reason why a club of Arsenal’s level should have failed to bring in a total of one bona fide superstar over the last decade. Although there’s still more than a month left of the transfer window remaining, Arsenal’s track record in this area over preceding years speaks for itself - it would be almost unprecedented if Arsenal were to somehow make things work. At this point it wouldn’t even be surprising if Arsenal were to lose Gyökeres to United.
Every off-season it appears as though Arsenal enter the transfer window without a coherent plan and as a result start the new season several steps behind their direct league rivals. As of right now, it seems as though this will once again be the case in the 2025-26 season. Once again, Arsenal don’t seem likely to have the personnel to be taken seriously as a genuine league title contender as the new season approaches.
If Arsenal are to win the Premier League title for the first time since 2004, it’s all but necessary that they must sign not only Gyökeres, but also several other key additions - and not questionable signings like Noni Madueke.
Wednesday, April 10, 2024
The Weekly Take, Issue 305: A Huge Chance Squandered?
If ever there was an opportunity for Arsenal to establish themselves as a genuine contender to win this season’s Champions League, the first leg of their quarterfinal fixture against Bayern Munich was exactly that. With their Bavarian opponents at their weakest point in more than a decade and struggling for form ahead of their trip to the Emirates Stadium, Arsenal had a clear chance to capitalize and take an important lead going into the second leg in Munich.
Instead, the Gunners came up short as they only managed a 2-2 draw. Arsenal actually got off to a strong start with Bukayo Saka opening the scoring in the 12th minute, only for Serge Gnabry to score against his former club six minutes later and bring the score to 1-1. Then, as he had so often done during his legendary 12-year stint at Arsenal’s North London arch-rivals Tottenham Hotspur, Harry Kane put his name on the scoresheet - this time via a penalty earned by Leroy Sané. Substitute Leandro Trossard would later score Arsenal’s equalizer to ensure that Arsenal would not enter the second leg a goal behind.
For Arsenal, this result can’t be described as anything other than a blown chance. Having a home match against one of the pre-tournament favorites who happened to be in turmoil on and off the field just then while Arsenal themselves lead the Premier League heading into the home stretch as they edge closer to a first league title in 20 years should’ve been exactly what they needed to get the jump on Bayern ahead of the second leg.
Instead, for large portions of the match, Arsenal were clearly outplayed. Arsenal’s back five, goalkeeper David Raya included, were rather shaky for most of the match and could certainly have done more to prevent Gnabry from having the goalscoring opportunity of which he took full advantage. In addition, Saliba’s foul on Sané to concede the penalty capped off a sequence of poor defensive play, particularly from Brazilian centre-back Gabriel.
Up until Arsenal brought in some of their substitutes, things weren’t going so well on the offensive front either apart from Saka. Kai Havertz looked more like the player who consistently underwhelmed during his three years at Chelsea than the player he’s been this season - someone who’s having a “comeback” season in what’s been his best year since leaving Bayer Leverkusen in 2020. As for Gabriel Martinelli, Bayern’s defense had him in their pocket from opening kick-off until he was unsurprisingly yanked in the 65th minute.
The biggest positive that Arsenal can take from this match regards their strategic and tactical adjustments. Mikel Arteta easily outcoached his Bayern counterpart Thomas Tuchel (to be fair, that isn’t a difficult thing to do these days), bringing in Trossard and Gabriel Jesus at just the right times and ultimately ensuring that Arsenal would head to Germany on level footing. The two substitutes would go on to combine for Arsenal’s equalizing goal.
Spearheaded by Arteta who at one point was almost fired from his position, Arsenal’s turnaround over the past two seasons has been impressive indeed. However, Arsenal’s sub-par performance on the biggest stage when the moment arrived highlighted how far Arsenal still have to go to become bona fide Champions League title contenders. The only consolation for Arsenal is the fact that this is the first leg, allowing them to regroup and potentially beat Bayern at the Allianz Arena.
Based on their respective levels of play throughout this season, one would expect Arsenal to take the win in the second leg and advance to the Champions League semifinals for the first time since the 2008-09 season. However, the first leg clearly showed that while Arsenal are definitely capable of beating Bayern away, the real question is if they will have the mental wherewithal to do so as well. It also has to be mentioned that fatigue could play a role - unlike Arsenal, Bayern are already out of contention for their domestic league title and thus can afford to rotate their squad to keep their best players fresh for the second leg.
Of course, with the aggregate score still tied at 2-2, Arsenal can’t be written off by any means. However, should they lose to Bayern in the second leg and exit the Champions League at the quarterfinal stage, this first-leg draw will undoubtedly be regarded as a golden opportunity blown.
Monday, April 10, 2023
The Weekly Take, Issue 252: The Beginning of a Title Challenge Unraveling?
Sunday, November 6, 2022
The Weekly Take, Issue 235: Finally Elite Again
Wednesday, March 16, 2022
The Weekly Take, Issue 202: A Critical Missed Opportunity
Prior to their Premier League match against Liverpool, Arsenal's season had been turning for the better after a slow start. With nine win in their preceding 11 league matches including five in a row, the Gunners should have been primed to give Liverpool all that they could handle - especially with Liverpool superstar Mohamed Salah restricted to an appearance off the bench due to a foot injury.
However, the match did not go according to plan for Arsenal at all. In a stark demonstration of the gulf in quality between the two teams, Liverpool beat Arsenal 2-0 despite not even exerting anywhere near their maximum level of effort. Diogo Jota scored Liverpool's first goal before being substituted almost immediately; his replacement, Roberto Firmino, wasted almost no time in adding to Liverpool's lead.
Arsenal will certainly rue this loss because a victory would have seen them move four points ahead of Manchester United and solidified their grip on fourth place and the last qualification spot for next season's Champions League. More than anything else, though, this match once again exposed some of Arsenal's most pertinent weaknesses which might just cause them to miss out on the top four.
One important question that hasn't been addressed all season long and has become even more relevant following the departure of Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang to Barcelona is this: do Arsenal really know who makes up their best attacking midfield trio? Choosing between Bukayo Saka, Emile Smith Rowe, Martin Ødegaard, and Gabriel Martinelli can prove to be quite the issue, especially now that Aubameyang has left, making Alexandre Lacazette the club's only starter-level striker. Even at this late stage of the season, the evidence on display during the Liverpool match clearly shows that Arsenal still haven't gotten it quite right in this area; if they end up surrendering their spot in the top four, this could have turned out to have been the main reason behind their downfall.
In the upcoming off-season, it might also be prudent for Arsenal to consider signing a new starting goalkeeper. Aaron Ramsdale has been rather inconsistent all season long; there are stretches when he saves just about anything but follows up those hot streaks with errors like the one he committed to allow Liverpool their first goal. Ramsdale is no scrub by any means, but is he really the goalkeeper upon whom Arsenal would like to stake their long-term future? Unfortunately, I just don't see it. He has not always been able to deliver at that level when it has most been needed.
Going back to the other end of the field, it's time to question Lacazette as well. This season, the Frenchman has scored a paltry four league goals. If he finishes the season at his current goalscoring rate, he will end the campaign with just six - his lowest tally in nine years and by far the lowest of his career at the Emirates Stadium. Not only that - at the age of 30, Lacazette does not fit this team's timeline. Arsenal have a young squad; most of their key players are 25 or younger. It does not make sense to continue to make a player who will soon be on the downswing of his career (if he isn't already there) one of the main components of the team.
There can be little doubt that this season has been very much better for Arsenal than was their disaster of a campaign in 2020-21. They do have an intriguing young core - albeit one without an ace like Aubameyang in his prime. That being said, their weaknesses continue to be glaring in many ways. It seems as though Arsenal have a clear idea of what should come next in the post-Aubameyang era, but they have not taken many, if any, steps in that direction.
Arsenal have not had a wider window of opportunity in years, given the ongoing struggles of United, Tottenham Hotspur, and most notably of all, Chelsea. Whether they will take advantage of this opportunity, though, remains to be seen. Although Arsenal might be in a solid position at the moment with regard to their league performance, it cannot be disputed: the only thing consistent about this Arsenal team is their inconsistency.
Saturday, November 20, 2021
The Weekly Take, Issue 185: It Was Just a False Dawn
Friday, August 2, 2019
The Weekly Take, Issue 74: A Most Unlikely Purchase
Arsenal have always been known as a club who have been cautious in the transfer window.
Now, while I do not believe that Pépé will play poorly during his stint at the London club, I consider this a mistake on Arsenal's part.
As Pépé is still only 24, his high transfer fee is both the product of current performance as well as projected future potential. However, it does not seem as though he has the ceiling of a true superstar. While this fact might not be a problem in and of itself, when a club signs a player for that high a transfer fee, the club ought to expect the player to be able to deliver at such a level.
Pépé did have a breakout campaign at Lille during the 2018-19 season. He scored an impressive 22 league goals and handed out 11 assists to lead Les Dogues to second place in Ligue 1.
However, it ought to be noted that he did not do this in one of Europe's major leagues. Thus, the level of competition that he faced every week was lower than what was encountered by some other rising stars such as Luka Jović, Joshua Kimmich, Sergej Milinković-Savić, Richarlison, and Leroy Sané, among others. Since the level of play in the Premier League is much higher than that of Ligue 1, Pépé may find it difficult to adapt; in fact, there is even a slight possibility that he never does so and struggles throughout his time in England, though that is the absolute worst-case scenario.
The addition of Pépé to the current Arsenal team also seems somewhat redundant. This is due to the fact that Aubameyang, who is clearly Arsenal's best player, is currently on the roster.
Pépé is a player whose style of play is very similar to that of the Gabonese striker. Able to play on either wing or at centre-forward, Pépé often uses his blistering speed to leave defenders behind him when moving inside from out wide.
This description is almost an exact copy of a description which could have been used to describe Aubameyang, particularly during his Borussia Dortmund days when he was younger and more athletic. Arsenal could easily have used the money spent on Pépé to sign a player such as Richarlison, Jović, Sébastien Haller, or Cengiz Ünder - young players of similar or higher calibre and who are all better fits alongside Aubameyang and Alexandre Lacazette up front.
One area in which Arsenal erred in this transfer window was their failure to make any notable transfers until July 25, when they signed William Saliba from Saint-Étienne. By this point, teams such as Real Madrid, Juventus, and Bayern Munich had all made multiple major signings. Even domestically, the likes of Manchester City and Tottenham had both landed a signing of note well before Arsenal did. This therefore artificially inflated Pépé's price - typically, the later in the transfer window the player is signed, the more inflated the transfer fee.
Now, I don't think this transfer is completely negative for Arsenal. Pépé is a clear upgrade over Alex Iwobi and should move straight into Arsenal's starting 11. There is definitely some potential in him, as was shown by his impressive 2018-19 season. He can definitely be a solid starter at the Emirates Stadium this season.
However, when the player in question is signed for €79 million, you expect much more than just "solid starter". You expect a star, and I do not believe Pépé will ever become one.
If this transfer is anything to go by, Arsenal fans can once again expect a difficult season after a below-par transfer window - a common refrain for the club over the last decade.