Sunday, July 20, 2025

The Weekly Take, Issue 371: Another Botched Transfer Window?

Not long after returning from the United States with the Club World Cup in possession after destroying Paris Saint-Germain in the final, Chelsea soon picked up another W - this time off the field; specifically, after flat-out scamming Arsenal in their sale of winger Noni Madueke to their London rivals for a transfer fee of £48.5 million.


In the two seasons and a half that Madueke spent at Chelsea, he showed absolutely nothing even remotely resembling the level of play that would’ve merited his hefty transfer fee. While Madueke is no scrub by any means, based on what we’ve seen from him so far, his ceiling isn’t anywhere near as high as his transfer fee - almost one and a half times his projected transfer value - might indicate.


As for Arsenal, they appear to be once again fumbling the transfer window - the main reason why the Gunners haven’t won a title of any sort since their FA Cup victory in the 2019-20 season. This can clearly be seen not only by the fact that they significantly overpaid for Madueke, but also in how they’re struggling to close out a huge transfer deal that seemed to be a lock not too long ago: the signing of Swedish striker Viktor Gyökeres.


After looking so close to landing by far their biggest signing since Pierre-Emerick Aubameyang from Borussia Dortmund in January 2018, progress on Gyökeres’ move to Arsenal has stalled and even more gallingly, might be beaten to the punch by Manchester United - a team which finished just 15th in the Premier League last season in what was their worst league campaign in 51 years and realistically should have no business landing a player on Gyökeres’ level.


If Arsenal are to seriously challenge Liverpool and Manchester City on the domestic front next season, they absolutely have to get things right in the transfer window. Instead, what they’ve been doing so far has been the exact opposite. Going back to the signing of Madueke, it was an obvious panic move which showed absolutely no forethought whatsoever; on top of the excessive transfer fee, it remains to be seen just how he will slot into Arsenal’s starting 11 - if he even can. There’s a possibility that Arsenal just spent all that money to bring in an expensive benchwarmer.


The argument that Arsenal don’t have the financial might that City do isn’t a viable one either; Liverpool just won the league by a landslide last season and they too aren’t working with that kind of budget. For years now Arsenal have been playing catch-up in the transfer window; if not for that, it’s very possible that Arsenal’s trophy drought wouldn’t have stretched to five years by now.


To put into perspective how pessimistic Arsenal fans are about the Madueke signing, after it was confirmed that it was likely that Madueke would be signing for Arsenal, many Arsenal fans took the the internet with the hashtag #NoToMadueke. While it’s of course not out of the question that Madueke defies the critics and has a career-best year in his first season at the Emirates Stadium, everything around the move is really not looking good as of right now.


There’s no good reason why a club of Arsenal’s level should have failed to bring in a total of one bona fide superstar over the last decade. Although there’s still more than a month left of the transfer window remaining, Arsenal’s track record in this area over preceding years speaks for itself - it would be almost unprecedented if Arsenal were to somehow make things work. At this point it wouldn’t even be surprising if Arsenal were to lose Gyökeres to United.


Every off-season it appears as though Arsenal enter the transfer window without a coherent plan and as a result start the new season several steps behind their direct league rivals. As of right now, it seems as though this will once again be the case in the 2025-26 season. Once again, Arsenal don’t seem likely to have the personnel to be taken seriously as a genuine league title contender as the new season approaches.


If Arsenal are to win the Premier League title for the first time since 2004, it’s all but necessary that they must sign not only Gyökeres, but also several other key additions - and not questionable signings like Noni Madueke. 

No comments:

Post a Comment